Week 9 •
LaVell Edwards Stadium

Arizona State20 @FINAL 27BYU , Week 9, Oct 31, 2026

4-3 Big 12 Power rating: 2.6
6-1 Big 12 Power rating: 15.3

How did the line hold up?

Market line
BYU -16.5
PM Implied
BYU -12.7
Blue Chip model
BYU -15.9
Edge
-0.6ASU
See details
◂ favors ASUfavors BYU ▸Market: BYU -16.5
12.7 › BYU
Adjust the power ratings by team
The power ratings row was edited directly, please click reset to adjust by team
BYU
no impact
no impact
BYU
no impact
1 ASU1 BYU2 ASU2 BYU3 ASU3 BYUModel: BYU -15.9

Betting information

Spread
BYU -16.5
Total
47.5
Odds implied score
ASU 15.5 – 32.0 BYU
Prediction markets
BYU 88% win chance (Kalshi)

DraftKings · as of October 31, 2026

BYU defeated Arizona State 27–20 in a one-score game. Arizona State covered by 9.5; Game went Under by 0.5. The market closed at BYU -16.5 and the Blue Chip model made it BYU -15.9. The two were within a point of each other, so there was no meaningful edge in this line.

What are the key factors for Arizona State vs BYU?

Arizona State

Arizona State's quarterback room is a three-way injury and performance crisis, and the market is pricing a functional offense that does not exist offenseFavorsBYU

Cutter Boley was benched at Texas Tech after going 5 of 10 with two interceptions, then went 1 of 5 for seven yards and was booed by the home crowd against Kansas State. Mikey Keene, the veteran who replaced him, left that game with an apparent leg injury in the final minute of the first half, and Kenny Dillingham said freshman Jake Fette will start if Keene cannot play. Fette had attempted two passes all season before rallying the Sun Devils against Kansas State. The market has BYU as a heavy favorite, which is fair, but the line implicitly assumes ASU gets competent quarterback play, and that is the single least certain thing about this team. The direction of value is toward BYU, and the strength is heavy, because the most likely outcome is a freshman making his first road start in a hostile venue against a 6-1 team.

Arizona State's pass defense has been shredded by every competent quarterback it has faced, and BYU is the best passing test since Texas Tech defenseFavorsBYU

The Sun Devils gave up 564 yards to Baylor and 502 to Texas Tech, with the Red Raiders scoring on seven consecutive first-half drives. Marcel Reed carved them up at Texas A&M. The common thread is that when C.J. Fite and the edge rushers do not generate pressure with four, the secondary (Ashton Stamps, Rodney Bimage Jr., Lyrik Rawls) cannot hold up. The only games where ASU's defense looked stout were against Morgan State (FCS), a Hawai'i team that is 1-5, and a Kansas State team starting a fifth-year senior making his first career start. BYU is 6-1 with a power rating far above Baylor's and Texas Tech's, and the Cougars have the athletes to stress both levels. This is the clearest path for BYU to cover a large number, and it is a bigger concern than the market's heavy lean toward the Cougars already reflects.

Cardae Mack has become Arizona State's offensive identity, and a run-heavy script is the one thing that can keep this game within the number offenseFavors neither

Mack ran for 154 yards and two scores against Hawai'i, then 159 yards and four touchdowns on 26 carries against Kansas State, the most rushing yards by an ASU freshman since 2005. With the quarterback position in flux, the Sun Devils' best path is to lean on Mack and the offensive line, control the clock, and keep BYU's offense off the field. That is exactly the script that produced the Kansas State win, when ASU held the Wildcats to 84 yards rushing and won the line of scrimmage on both sides. The concern is that BYU's front seven is far better than Kansas State's, and a one-dimensional offense with a freshman quarterback is easy to defend. This cuts both ways: it is ASU's best chance to stay close, but it is also a recipe for a low-scoring game that BYU wins comfortably.

Arizona State finally gets a normal road trip and a full week of rest, but BYU's venue advantage is the strongest ASU has faced situationalFavorsBYU

After logging over 6,700 travel miles, including a 5,271-mile one-way trip to London and road games at Texas A&M and Texas Tech, ASU makes a short 471-mile trip to Provo with a full seven days of rest. That is the cleanest situational setup the Sun Devils have had for a road game all season, and it is a real counterweight to the quarterback and defensive concerns. But BYU's venue advantage is the strongest ASU has faced, and the Cougars are 6-1 against the spread, meaning they have consistently separated from quality opponents. The market has BYU as a heavy favorite, and the rest and travel factors are not enough to close that gap. The direction of value is toward BYU, and the strength is modest, because the situational edge ASU gains from a normal week is real but small compared to the talent and venue gap.

The market is more confident in BYU than the Cougars' 6-1 record and ASU's home win over Kansas State justify marketFavorsArizona State

The line has BYU as a massive home favorite and the prediction market gives the Cougars an overwhelming win probability. But BYU is 6-1 against the spread, which means the market has been consistently high on the Cougars all season, and this line may be an overcorrection. Arizona State just beat Kansas State 28-17 at home, holding the Wildcats to 84 yards rushing, and the Sun Devils have now won two of their last three. The losses to Texas A&M, Baylor and Texas Tech were all to teams better than this BYU team, and two of those came on the road. The market's confidence in BYU is stronger than this matchup warrants, and the direction of value is slightly toward Arizona State, because a heavy favorite coming off a strong ATS run is often priced at its ceiling.

BYU

BYU's defense has been the season's constant, and Arizona State's offense is the weakest it has faced since the opener defenseFavorsBYU

Kelly Poppinga's unit has answered every step up in class: four turnovers forced against Utah Tech, a second-half shutout of Arizona in which the Wildcats managed minus-2 rushing yards after halftime, six total yards allowed to Iowa State in the second quarter (200 for the game, the Cyclones' fewest since 2018), and 259 yards allowed at TCU. The one blemish was UCF, where Keyone Jenkins threw for 293 yards and three touchdowns and Tyren Hornes went for 137, but that came on a cross-country trip against a quarterback playing the best game of his career. Arizona State arrives at 4-3 with a power rating far below every Power 4 opponent BYU has beaten, and the Sun Devils have not seen a front with Keanu Tanuvasa and Cade Uluave or a safety like Faletau Satuala, whose fourth-down interception at TCU set up a touchdown. Back in Provo, with the crowd and altitude that helped force four turnovers in the opener, this is the clearest edge in the matchup.

The market is treating BYU as a near-lock, but the Cougars have not covered a number this large against a competent opponent all season marketFavorsArizona State

The line and the prediction market have BYU as a heavy home favorite, which is a bigger ask than anything the Cougars have delivered against a team with a pulse. Their six covers came against Utah Tech, Arizona, Colorado State, TCU, Iowa State and Notre Dame, and the Notre Dame cover was as a double-digit underdog, not a favorite. As a favorite, BYU beat Arizona by 11, Colorado State by 18, TCU by 7, Iowa State by 14 and UCF not at all, and the TCU and UCF games showed the offense bogging down: 216 total yards in Fort Worth and a fourth-down incompletion at the UCF 4 that ended the game. The market is more confident in a blowout than BYU's own scoring profile justifies, so the value leans toward Arizona State covering even though BYU should win.

Bear Bachmeier has become the entire offense, and the fourth-down and special-teams mistakes are piling up offenseFavorsArizona State

Since LJ Martin went down in the first quarter at TCU, Bachmeier has carried the load: 66 rushing yards on 15 carries against the Horned Frogs, a career-best 109 rushing yards and 329 passing yards against Iowa State, and against Notre Dame he ran for two touchdowns, caught another and threw the go-ahead score, becoming the first quarterback since Steve Young in the 1983 Holiday Bowl with a passing, rushing and receiving touchdown in the same game. But the workload is heavy and the supporting details are slipping: BYU went 0-of-3 on fourth down against Iowa State with two failures inside the 5, and against Notre Dame a muffed punt and a failed fake punt let the Irish back into a game BYU led 21-10 at halftime. Against UCF the Cougars drove to the 4 in the second overtime and Bachmeier's fourth-down pass to Walker Lyons fell incomplete. If Martin remains limited, Arizona State can load up against Bachmeier and dare someone else to beat them, which is exactly how UCF and TCU kept these games close.

The situational setup flips back in BYU's favor after the Orlando loss: home in Provo, no travel, full rest, and a bye ahead situationalFavorsBYU

The UCF loss was the season's only road game beyond a 347-mile commute to Colorado State and a 949-mile flight to TCU, and it came at a venue with a home-field rating higher than any BYU had visited, after the emotional high of beating Notre Dame. This week the Cougars are back in Provo with zero travel, a full week of rest and the same home-field rating that has propped up every home game this season, and Arizona State must come to altitude. BYU has played four of seven games at home and won all of them, and the crowd and altitude helped force four turnovers in the opener and hold Iowa State to 200 yards. The one caveat is that the Cougars have a trip to Utah looming, but with a bye presumably following, there is no look-ahead excuse here. The situational factors that worked against BYU in Orlando are now working for them.

BYU's takeaway-to-points habit is real, but it has depended on opponents handing over short fields that Arizona State may not defenseFavors neither

The Cougars have turned several takeaways into immediate points: a 9-yard drive after Cade Uluave's interception against Arizona, a 16-yard drive after Faletau Satuala's fourth-down pick at TCU, and a fumble recovery at the BYU 5 against Notre Dame that preserved a two-score halftime lead. They have also scored touchdowns on six of eight red-zone drives against Utah Tech. But the hidden edge has been uneven against better competition: UCF protected the ball well enough to win, and Notre Dame's only turnover was a fumbled spike. Arizona State is 4-3 and 3-4 against the spread, which suggests a team that hangs around without giving games away. If BYU does not win the turnover battle, it will have to drive the length of the field against a defense that has not allowed many clean drives, and the offense's fourth-down struggles make that a less reliable path than the market's heavy home-favorite pricing assumes.

What were the weather conditions for Arizona State vs BYU?

At kickoff, conditions at LaVell Edwards Stadium were Thundery outbreaks in nearby, 58°F with winds of 2 mph. Weather is not expected to be a meaningful factor in this game. Historical weather data for this game is preserved in the panel alongside. Weather data is sourced from WeatherAPI.com.

What happened in the game?

Arizona State travels 471 miles to this game, a moderate road trip.

Arizona State arrives with a 1-hour eastward body clock shift, short of the two-zone westward threshold where travel starts to price.

BYU won by 7 in a one-score game.

Arizona State covered the spread by a solid margin.

The total went Under by 0.5 points.

How do Arizona State and BYU compare on power ratings?

Blue Chip Analytics power ratings favor BYU (15.3) over Arizona State (2.6) by 12.7 points on a neutral field. After adding home field advantage, the rating-implied line may differ meaningfully from the market spread. BYU brings a meaningful home field advantage to this matchup (Blue Chip HFA: 2.8). Add this to the neutral-site differential to arrive at a venue-adjusted line.

Blue Chip Analytics power ratings represent expected point margin against an average FBS opponent on a neutral field, calculated from game data sourced via CollegeFootballData.com (CFBD). They are one input: cross-reference with the travel, rest, and weather data above before drawing conclusions.

Sources

Weather

BYU won and Arizona State covered the spread.

Conditions

as of October 31, 2026 Game-time

Thundery outbreaks in nearby

58°F

Rain18%
Precip0.00"
Humidity55%
Wind2 mph WSW
Gusts5 mph
Wind map for Arizona State at BYU: aerial view of LaVell Edwards Stadium, wind from the WSW at 2 mph, gusting to 4.9 mph

Quick facts

Week
Week 9
Kickoff (local)
01:30 PM MDT
Venue
LaVell Edwards Stadium
Capacity
62,073
Elevation
4,678 ft
Surface
Grass

Travel and rest

Measure Arizona StateAway BYUHome
This week471 miles0 miles
Last weekHome game3,807 miles
Season total14,045 miles6,398 miles
Body clock12:3013:30
Rest7 days7 days